If you changed jobs in 2026, check box 4, Social Security tax withheld, on your W-2s. With two or more employers and combined wages above $184,500, you likely overpaid Social Security tax. You get the excess back on your federal return, but only if you claim it.
Why two employers lead to overpayment
For 2026, Social Security tax applies to the first $184,500 of wages at 6.2%. The annual maximum per person is $11,439.00.
Each employer generally withholds up to that limit on wages it pays, without accounting for another employer’s withholding. Both can withhold correctly while you overpay overall.
How you get it back, and when you can’t
Two or more employers: Claim withholding above $11,439.00 as a credit on your 2026 Form 1040 using Schedule 3 (“Other Payments and Refundable Credits”). On the current form, that’s line 11. It reduces your balance due or increases your refund.
One employer withheld too much: You can’t claim that excess on your return. Ask the employer to correct it. If it doesn’t, file Form 843 with W-2 copies.
Married filing jointly: Calculate each spouse’s excess separately; you can’t combine wages. A spouse whose wages from all their employers stayed under $184,500 has nothing to claim, regardless of household earnings.
The opposite problem: Additional Medicare Tax
Regular Medicare tax (1.45% for employees) applies to all wages without a limit; changing jobs doesn’t cause an overpayment. The 0.9% Additional Medicare Tax can create a shortfall.
It applies to Medicare wages above $200,000 (single, head of household, or qualifying surviving spouse), $250,000 (married filing jointly), or $125,000 (married filing separately). Employers withhold only on wages they pay above $200,000 in the calendar year, regardless of your filing status or wages from other jobs. If each employer paid less than $200,000, neither may have withheld, despite combined wages exceeding your threshold. Calculate the tax on Form 8959 and pay with your return.
Working two jobs at once?
The same Social Security rule applies to simultaneous W-2 jobs. Each employer withholds on its wages up to $184,500; excess combined withholding over $11,439 becomes a return credit.
Income tax withholding needs attention: each payroll sees only its wages. IRS Pub. 505 says withholding is most likely to be off with simultaneous jobs. Step 2 of the 2026 Form W-4 addresses this: use the IRS Tax Withholding Estimator or Multiple Jobs Worksheet, or, for only two jobs, check Step 2(c) on both W-4s. California’s DE 4 suggests “Single or Married (with two or more incomes),” all allowances at the higher-paying job, zero at the other, and extra withholding on line 2 if your employer agrees.
Additional Medicare Tax withholding starts only when one employer pays over $200,000. Federal (Form 1040-ES) and California (Form 540-ES) estimated payments can cover remaining shortfalls.
Worked example (hypothetical numbers)
Single filer, two employers in 2026, wages only.
| Employer A (Jan–Jun) | Employer B (Jul–Dec) | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wages | $150,000 | $120,000 | $270,000 |
| Social Security withheld (6.2%) | $9,300 | $7,440 | $16,740 |
- 2026 maximum: $184,500 × 6.2% = $11,439.00
- Excess: $16,740 − $11,439 = $5,301, claimed as a credit on the 2026 return
Additional Medicare Tax: Neither employer paid more than $200,000, so neither withheld it. Amount owed: 0.9% × ($270,000 − $200,000) = $630, figured on Form 8959.
One-employer contrast (hypothetical): An employer pays $200,000 and withholds 6.2% on all of it, which is $12,400. That’s $961 over the $11,439 maximum. Because one employer caused it, it’s not a Schedule 3 credit. The employer has to correct it, or you file Form 843.
What to do before year-end
- Check year-to-date Social Security withheld on your latest paystub from each 2026 employer.
- If one employer alone has withheld more than $11,439, ask payroll to correct it now.
- Check Additional Medicare Tax against wages from every job. Topic 560 notes extra W-4 withholding or estimated payments can cover it.
- For safe harbor planning: Pub. 505 lets you count expected excess Social Security as withholding when wages from two or more employers exceed $184,500.
- In January, compare box 4 on each W-2 with final paystubs.
- Looking ahead: the Social Security wage base rises to $192,300 for 2027, so the 2027 maximum is $11,922.60.
If your 2026 job change included a sign-on bonus, severance, or RSUs from both employers, I’m happy to set up a consult to review the whole year.
This post is general information, not tax advice for your situation.